« Sea legs | Main

July 01, 2005

O'Connor leaves the Supremes

Justice O'Connor just announced her decision to resign from the Supreme Court.  O'Connor, a conservative, could always be counted not to rely upon neo-con ideology and instead render a thoughtful and well reasoned opinion. 

In these times when our country is terribly polarized, leaders like O'Connor, who are willing to consider both sides of an issue are desperately needed.  It is unlikely that Justice O'Connor will be replaced by someone who has her strengths.

If Dubya decided to replace Justice O'Connor with a female jurist, she may be replaced by Edith Hollan Jones.  She's on the short list submitted to the current administration by the Christian Legal Society.  (Samuel Alito, a 3rd U.S. Circuit judge from Philadelphia, and Michael W. McConnell, on the 10th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals were also recommended, as possible candidates by The Christian Legal Society.)

Judge Jones practiced law in Texas and now sits on the 5th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals in New Orleans.  A really ugly Title VII dissent to her discredit proves that Judge Jones lacks Justice O'Connor's capacity for critical thought and reason.  Harriet Miers, another Texas lawyer, and White House Counsel would be a much better choice.  Ms. Miers is widely respected by all those who know her.

But my money is on Emilio Garza of the 5th Circuit.  Garzo could give Dubya the chance to name the first Hispanic justice.  Alberto Gonzales, might have otherwise been in the running, but is now unsuited for nomination in light of his memo that provided that detainees could be subjected to torture without running afoul of the Geneva Convention.

Slate has a good article outlining those in line to take O'Connor's spot.

Actuarial tables alone suggest that Dubya will be able to name at least two new justices, and perhaps as many as four.   Chief Justice Rehnquist, 80, suffers from thyroid cancer, and will likely announce his retirement in the next week or so.  Justices John Paul Stevens is 85.  And Ruth Bader Ginsburg, 72, has also been treated for cancer.

Posted by dog2 on July 1, 2005 at 08:39 AM in Legal | Permalink

TrackBack

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.typepad.com/services/trackback/6a00d8341fc28f53ef00d8341fc29053ef

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference O'Connor leaves the Supremes:

» Buy MP3 Music Online - Digital Music Downloads from MP3 Music
MP3 Music Downloads - MP3.com offers links to legal digital music downloads from a wide variety of services. Buy MP3 music online from your favorite artists ... [Read More]

Tracked on May 3, 2006 3:31:25 AM

Comments

You mean a little thing like approving the use of torture might keep him from being nominated? I thought his lack of a strong position against abortion represented a greater obstacle.

Posted by: Dawg60 | Jul 9, 2005 9:35:55 AM

A really smart dog mused that we should "get ready for the soul crushing reality of progressives in america remaining silent as gonzales, the crafter of language enabling torture, is nominated. he is the best bet dems have probably, being soft on abortion. take your pick, abortion or torture. which do you care more about."

But I think that you are right, Bush will never nominate him because he is soft on abortion. Emilio Garza is a more likely pick, as a result.

Posted by: dog 2 | Jul 11, 2005 11:15:30 AM

Surprise, surprise. An average white male...

Posted by: dawg60 | Aug 21, 2005 8:20:06 AM

Roberts is not so average, I think. He's smart, clearly much smarter than the senators on the Judiciary Committee. I think he'll be a really good Chief Justice of the Supreme Court. And while I know that he is a conservative, I actually prefer a Supreme Court justice to be conservative, as long as he's not a idealogue, a fatefull bullet to reasoning that I think Roberts has dodged.

Posted by: dog 2 | Sep 21, 2005 8:38:52 AM

very good blog !!! i love !!! good job ;-)

Posted by: Bob le Chien | Jan 17, 2006 11:55:39 PM

Wow, I wasnt looking for this blog and actually just stubled on it, But just goes to show how powerful google is

http://www.myhummer3.com

Posted by: Joe | Feb 13, 2006 7:48:23 PM

Interesting to read this after the fact and the final selection of TWO justices.

Posted by: tim | Jun 26, 2006 11:05:49 AM

4freeonlinecreditreport.com

credit free report, free credit report online, credit report trans union, credit dispute report, credit free one report time, credit free report yearly, copy credit free report, com credit free report, california credit free report, credit free report texas, get credit report free online, credit free ohio report, credit free missouri report, credit free indiana report, credit free new report york, credit free jersey new report, arizona credit free report, 3 in 1 credit report, 100 credit free report, credit rating report, free uk online credit report, credit free online report uk, credit get report, free instant online credit report, bad credit repair report
anti-aging-wrinkle-cream.net

cream pie, cream, wrinkle cream, wrinkle cream, anal cream pie, teen cream pie, shaving cream, skin cream, eye cream, stretch mark cream, anti wrinkle cream, black cream pie, asian cream pie, facial cream, acne creams, skin care cream, face cream, anti aging cream, cream puffs, dripping cream pie, moms cream pie, cream girl got, hair removal cream, best wrinkle cream, best anti wrinkle cream

Posted by: link123 | Aug 5, 2006 12:03:35 AM

debt consolidation loan
student loan debt consolidation
bad credit debt consolidation loan
unsecured debt consolidation loan
personal debt consolidation loan
credit card debt consolidation loan
mortgage loan refinance and debt consolidation
debt consolidation mortgage loan
debt consolidation home equity loan
debt consolidation home loan
debt consolidation loan rate
low interest debt consolidation loan
debt consolidation loan for non home owner
debt consolidation loan online
home loan equity loan debt consolidation mortgage
bad consolidation credit debt loan unsecured
debt consolidation secured loan
debt consolidation loan for home owner
christian debt consolidation loan
debt consolidation loan uk
government debt consolidation loan
debt consolidation loan for people with bad credit
poor credit debt consolidation loan
california debt consolidation loan
credit debt consolidation loan
consolidation debt loan personal unsecured
debt consolidation and personal loan for bad credit
florida debt consolidation loan
bad debt consolidation loan
consolidation debt iv loan
debt consolidation loan calculator
debt consolidation loan application
consolidation debt en language loan
consolidation debt loan payday
pennsylvania debt consolidation loan
student loan debt consolidation
student loan debt consolidation calculator
debt consolidation defaulted student loan
chiropractic consolidation debt loan student
canada consolidation debt loan loan student
consolidation consolidation debt debt loan student
consolidation debt graduate loan student

Posted by: Debt Consolidation loan | Oct 12, 2006 5:30:39 AM

It seems this blog is no longer being updated, but if you didn't already know, then I regret to inform you that Cass Brown has already died. He was a good man. If nothing else, do update the little tag under the blog name.

Posted by: | Feb 5, 2007 3:23:29 PM

CYTOMEL AND CYNOPLUS AVAILABLE FOR IMMEDIATE DELIVERY, with special discount for limited time. Welcome to the Pharmamx.com Family! We invite you to visit us at www.pharmamx.com and find our great medicine prices. We provide serious and first class service to all our customers 24/7. If we don’t carry a medicine you need just let us know and we will be more than glad to assist you! To show you our gratitude for past purchases and to offer you one more reason to continue purchasing with Pharmamx.com We are offering a limited time 30% discount include on all our medicines. We will keep on giving you the best price and service in the market. Welcome and enjoy your visit to www.pharmamx.com

Posted by: Eduardo Bernal | Feb 13, 2007 10:21:34 AM

Greetings,

Your posted was well informative, that every person who read or see this will get knowledge
about you posted. you made a great job for this and thank you for sharing your taughts
on us..More power!

Best Regards,
Mara Chui
Underground Fence

Posted by: Clara Santos | Apr 23, 2007 8:39:19 AM

http://yahoo-indici-mondiali.tuttianio.info
http://gioco-tree-tent.tuttianiu.info
http://mansarde-in-affitto-toscana.tuttianio.info
http://gabbana-gossip-excite-it.tuttianio.info
http://frosoni.tuttiania.info
http://estrarre-il-video-dai-dvd.tuttianie.info
http://mares-mr12.tuttianiy.info
http://constructoras-en-lima.tuttianie.info
http://costruzione-tavolo-biliardo.tuttianie.info
http://pipi-donna.tuttianiu.info
http://incontinenza-forum.tuttianio.info
http://far-soldo.tuttianiy.info
http://popolo-babilonese.tuttiania.info
http://basi-canzoni.tuttianiy.info
http://farmaco-antipertensivi.tuttianio.info
http://barra-sito.tuttianiu.info
http://cestaio.tuttianio.info
http://arkansas-department-of-education-standards.tuttiania.info
http://sperma-it.tuttianio.info
http://inquinanti-gassosi-aria-discarica-rsu.tuttianiy.info

Posted by: asda | May 21, 2007 5:34:27 PM

greetings,

Hi!!

A Pleasant warming for you at this day! I’d just leave a comment for what you posted
because I found it so informative just like what other had commented. Thank you very much
for sharing this on behalf of every body who already read this. And keep the good work..


More power,
Elisa Woods
http://www.petstroller-4less.com/

Posted by: Elisa Woods | May 30, 2007 10:08:30 AM

Search for in all major search engines simultaneously on the site http://www.iknowall.com.
Simultaneous search on Google, Yahoo and MSN Live Search.

Try http://www.iknowall.com

Posted by: iknowall | Jun 1, 2007 7:29:23 AM

Search for in all major search engines simultaneously on the site http://www.iknowall.com.
Simultaneous search on Google, Yahoo and MSN Live Search.

Try http://www.iknowall.com

Posted by: iknowall | Jun 1, 2007 10:50:38 AM

Cool guestbook!!!Phenk you ++++ [url=http://jorge1.info/vanna_white/how_old_is_vanna_white.html]how old is vanna white[/url][url=http://factyri.info/n_wild/n_shirt_wild.html]n shirt wild[/url][url=http://factyri.info/n_wild/wet_n_wild_lip_gloss.html]wet n wild lip gloss[/url][url=http://factyri.info/n_wild/wet_n_wild_cosmetic.html]wet n wild cosmetic[/url][url=http://jorge1.info/open_book/clip_art_of_an_open_book.html]clip art of an open book[/url][url=http://factyri.info/doggie_day_care/boarding_care_day_doggie.html]boarding care day doggie[/url][url=http://factyri.info/n_wild/nice_n_wild.html]nice n wild[/url][url=http://factyri.info/doggie_day_care/care_day_doggie_ohio.html]care day doggie ohio[/url][url=http://factyri.info/n_wild/wet_n_wild_fl.html]wet n wild fl[/url][url=http://jorge1.info/bine_e/bine_e_mai.html]bine e mai[/url][url=http://jorge1.info/flag_garden/flag_garden_mickey_mouse.html]flag garden mickey mouse[/url][url=http://jorge1.info/flag_garden/garden_flag_stands.html]garden flag stands[/url][url=http://factyri.info/n_wild/wild_n_out_mtv.html]wild n out mtv[/url][url=http://jorge1.info/open_book/open_book_pelvic_fracture.html]open book pelvic fracture[/url][url=http://jorge1.info/healing_inner_mind_quiet/healing_inner_mind_quiet.html]healing inner mind quiet[/url]

Posted by: Cool guestbook!!!Phenk you ++++ [url=http://jorge1.info/vanna_white/how_old_is_vanna_white.html]how | Jun 21, 2007 1:25:13 PM

http://ritalin-picture-ra.org/propranolol/en/propranolol-for-anxiety.html propranolol for anxietyhttp://ritalin-picture-ra.org/lexapro-withdrawal/en/lexapro-withdrawal-symptom.html lexapro withdrawal symptomhttp://ritalin-picture-ra.org/synthroid-dosage/sitemap.html synthroid dosagehttp://ritalin-picture-ra.org/order-soma/en/order-soma-carisoprodol.html order soma carisoprodolhttp://ritalin-picture-ra.org/propranolol-stuttering/sitemap.html propranolol stutteringhttp://ritalin-picture-ra.org/atacand/sitemap.html atacandhttp://ritalin-picture-ra.org/keppra-side-effects/sitemap.html keppra side effectshttp://ritalin-picture-ra.org/ortho-tri-cyclen/en/ortho.html orthohttp://ritalin-picture-ra.org/seroquel-weight-gain/en/ seroquel weight gainhttp://ritalin-picture-ra.org/xanax-valium/en/blog-valium-xanax.html blog valium xanaxhttp://ritalin-picture-ra.org/seasonale/sitemap.html seasonalehttp://ritalin-picture-ra.org/aciphex-medication/en/aciphex-medication-rebate.html aciphex medication rebatehttp://ritalin-picture-ra.org/city-of-norco/en/city-of-norco-ca.html city of norco cahttp://ritalin-picture-ra.org/ambien-cr-effects-side/en/ ambien cr effects sidehttp://ritalin-picture-ra.org/norco-home/en/corona-home-norco.html corona home norcohttp://ritalin-picture-ra.org/glipizide-er-5mg/en/ glipizide er 5mghttp://ritalin-picture-ra.org/actonel-side-effects/sitemap.html actonel side effectshttp://ritalin-picture-ra.org/ciprofloxacin-side-effects/en/ ciprofloxacin side effectshttp://ritalin-picture-ra.org/ultram-online/en/ ultram onlinehttp://ritalin-picture-ra.org/singulair/en/singulair-side-affect.html singulair side affecthttp://ritalin-picture-ra.org/hcl-oxycodone/en/5mg-hcl-oxycodone.html 5mg hcl oxycodonehttp://ritalin-picture-ra.org/fosamax-actonel/en/ fosamax actonelhttp://ritalin-picture-ra.org/yasmin-birth-control-pill/sitemap.html yasmin birth control pillhttp://ritalin-picture-ra.org/vioxx/en/lawsuit-vioxx.html lawsuit vioxxhttp://ritalin-picture-ra.org/buspar/en/buspar-side-effects.html buspar side effects

Posted by: purchase soma online | Jun 27, 2007 6:53:17 PM

Glad to see other.

Posted by: order xanax online | Aug 21, 2007 9:22:09 AM

I visited your web site.

Posted by: cheap levitra online | Aug 21, 2007 9:42:20 AM

Ok! Beautyful.

Posted by: buy phentermine in the uk | Aug 22, 2007 11:59:02 AM

Ok! Beautyful.

Posted by: xanax valium online | Aug 22, 2007 12:40:04 PM

People should be allowed to go naked in certain recreational areas only

Posted by: club | Sep 7, 2007 8:42:44 PM

Posted by: umsgcz | Sep 21, 2007 2:08:50 AM

rthy gykjwlcv qrithxs krtfzx cyjgosnwm hcnq xhojgtb

Posted by: mjibvs dfhmkxg | Sep 24, 2007 6:15:25 AM